Limitations Of Liability & Fee Adjustment

Section 1

Purpose

Every QS appointment carries the risk of a professional liability claim. Managing that liability exposure — through caps, net contribution clauses, and proportionate liability — is an essential commercial and professional skill. At the same time, fee adjustment provisions protect the firm when project scope or circumstances change after appointment.

This guidance note draws on the RICS Risk, Liability and Insurance Guidance Note (1st edition, April 2021) and the RICS Standard Form of Consultant's Appointment (May 2022), Clause 5.

Section 2

Key Principles

Liability

Aggregate Liability Cap (Clause 5.1): limits the total financial exposure of the consultant to a figure recorded in the Appendix. This should be set at a level commensurate with the project value and PII coverage — typically equal to or no more than the PII limit.
Net Contribution Clause (Clause 5.2): limits the QS's liability to its proportionate share of any loss, taking into account the contributory negligence of other parties (e.g., contractor, other consultants). Without it, a QS could be held liable for 100% of a loss caused partly by others.
Expiry of Liability (Clause 5.3): sets the period after which no claim can be made. For simple contracts, the Limitation Act 1980 allows 6 years. For deeds, 12 years. Clause 5.3 allows parties to agree a shorter period in the appointment.
Third Party Reliance (Clause 5.8): the consultant's duty of care is generally owed only to the contracting client. Disclosure of advice to third parties does not automatically create a duty of care to them. A formal reliance letter or Duty of Care Deed is required if the QS is to assume liability to a third party.
Unlimited liability should never be accepted without legal advice — it may exceed PII coverage and expose directors personally.

Fee Adjustment

The RICS Standard Form Clause 9.11–9.14 sets out how fees may be adjusted where the services are altered, delayed, or disrupted.
Clause 9.11: where additional services are instructed, the fee shall be adjusted in accordance with the rates and prices in the Appendix, or if not stated, on a time-charge basis.
Clause 9.12–9.14: where the project is suspended, delayed, or materially changed (including abandonment), the consultant may be entitled to additional fee. Documenting the impact of such events is essential to recover this entitlement.
Always issue a written variation to scope and fee before carrying out additional services — verbal instructions cannot be relied upon to support a later fee claim.

Section 3

Practical Application

Step 1

At appointment stage, agree and record the aggregate liability cap in the Appendix — typically set equal to your PII limit or the project construction cost, whichever is lower.

Step 2

Ensure the net contribution clause (Clause 5.2) is included and not deleted — this is a key commercial protection.

Step 3

Agree the expiry of liability period. Six years is standard for simple contracts; consider whether a shorter period is appropriate and negotiate accordingly.

Step 4

Do not agree to extend duty of care to third parties (funders, purchasers) without checking the impact on PII and taking legal advice.

Step 5

When additional services are instructed, issue a written variation notice before commencing. Record the scope, basis of fee, and programme impact.

Step 6

Keep a contemporaneous record of any project delays, suspensions, or scope changes that may entitle the firm to fee adjustment.

Section 4

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Accepting a liability cap that exceeds your PII limit — this creates an uninsured exposure.
Agreeing to delete the net contribution clause without understanding the risk — you could become solely liable for losses caused partly by others.
Not recording contemporaneous evidence of project delays or scope changes, making later fee recovery claims difficult to sustain.
Extending duty of care to third parties informally (by email or in reports) without formal Duty of Care Deeds, potentially creating uninsured liability.
Failing to issue written variation notices for additional work, leaving the firm unable to recover the additional fee.

Section 5

APC Competency & Quick Reference

This topic is relevant to: Contract Practice (Level 1–3), Business Management (Level 1–2), Risk Management, RICS Rules of Conduct.

What is an aggregate liability cap, and how should it be set in a QS appointment?

An aggregate cap (Clause 5.1 of the RICS Standard Form) limits the consultant's total financial liability to a fixed sum recorded in the Appendix. It should be set at a level that is covered by the firm's PII policy — typically equal to the PII limit. Accepting a cap higher than the PII limit creates an uninsured gap.

What is a net contribution clause, and why is it important?

A net contribution clause (Clause 5.2) limits the QS's liability to its proportionate share of any loss, having regard to the fault of other contributing parties. Without it, under joint and several liability principles, the QS could be required to pay 100% of a loss even if it was primarily caused by others — for example, a contractor or another consultant.

How can a QS protect its fee entitlement when a project is delayed or suspended?

By keeping contemporaneous records of the delay or suspension, its cause, and the impact on the QS's resource and programme. The RICS Standard Form (Clauses 9.11–9.14) provides a mechanism for fee adjustment in such circumstances, but the firm must be able to substantiate its entitlement with documented evidence.

What is the limitation period for a claim under a simple contract versus a deed?

Under the Limitation Act 1980, the limitation period is 6 years from breach for simple contracts and 12 years for deeds. Clause 5.3 of the RICS Standard Form allows parties to agree a shorter period, which can be commercially beneficial for the consultant.

Section 6

Pre-Appointment Checklist

☐

Aggregate liability cap agreed and recorded in the Appointment Appendix

☐

Cap confirmed as within PII limit — no uninsured exposure created

☐

Net contribution clause (Clause 5.2) included and not deleted

☐

Expiry of liability period agreed and recorded

☐

Third party reliance / duty of care extension considered — formal deed required if agreed

☐

Fee adjustment mechanism confirmed in appointment terms (Clauses 9.11–9.14)

☐

Variation procedure documented — written notice required before additional services commence

☐

Record-keeping system in place for project delays, scope changes, and additional instructions

Section 7

CPD Learning Outcomes

Explain the purpose and interaction of aggregate liability caps, net contribution clauses, and expiry of liability provisions in a QS appointment.
Apply the fee adjustment provisions of the RICS Standard Form to protect fee recovery when scope changes, delays, or suspensions occur.
Identify the risks of unlimited liability, excessive caps, and informal duty of care extensions.

Section 8